Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between The Westin St. John Resort Villas and Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, accommodations, dining, beach, activities, price & more so you can decide which resort fits your next Caribbean getaway.
Best for families and couples who want a villa-style St. John stay with kitchens, a private Great Cruz Bay beach, and a quieter resort rhythm.
Better for travelers who want a casual St. Thomas vacation-club setting with an island-party feel and easier access to St. Thomas arrival logistics.
If you want a polished villa resort on St. John with spacious accommodations, beach time on Great Cruz Bay, and strong family-friendly amenities, The Westin St. John Resort Villas is the better fit.
If your priority is a more casual, Margaritaville-branded St. Thomas stay with a laid-back vacation-club atmosphere, Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas is likely the easier match.
Bottom line: choose The Westin St. John Resort Villas for villa space, St. John scenery, and family amenities; choose Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas for a more relaxed St. Thomas base.
| Category | The Westin St. John Resort Villas | Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | Polished, family-friendly villa resort on Great Cruz Bay with a relaxed St. John feel, spacious accommodations, and resort amenities for all ages. | Casual island vacation-club atmosphere on St. Thomas with a more playful, easygoing Margaritaville style. |
| Location | On Great Cruz Bay in St. John, with guests typically flying into St. Thomas and transferring by private or public ferry. | On St. Thomas, making it the simpler choice for travelers who prefer to stay on the island where the main airport is located. |
| Rooms & Suites | Studios plus one-, two-, and three-bedroom villas and townhouses, many with kitchens or kitchenettes and added residential-style convenience. | Vacation-club style accommodations suited to travelers who want a casual island base rather than a traditional full-service hotel feel. |
| Dining | On-site options include casual beach and pool dining, a marketplace/café, and steak-and-seafood dining, with room service available during set periods. | Best for travelers who are comfortable with a casual resort dining setup and using St. Thomas as a base for additional dining off property. |
| Pools & Beach | Private white-sand beach along Great Cruz Bay, a large freshwater main pool, a whirlpool spa, and a children’s pool on site. | A St. Thomas resort setting with a relaxed pool-and-island vacation feel rather than the more secluded St. John villa-resort atmosphere. |
| Kids & Family | Strong family credentials, including the Westin Family Kids Club and villa layouts that work well for families and multi-bedroom stays. | All-ages vacation-club option for families or groups who want a casual St. Thomas stay with less emphasis on a villa-resort campus. |
| Price & Value | Best value for travelers who will use the larger villas, kitchens, beach, pool, watersports, and St. John setting. | Best value for travelers who prioritize a simpler St. Thomas base and a laid-back branded vacation-club experience. |
Accommodations at The Westin St. John Resort Villas are designed for longer, more residential-style island stays, with studios, villas, and townhouses that give families and groups room to settle in.
The Westin is the better pick if you want a true villa resort with more room to spread out and practical amenities for family stays.
Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas leans into a casual vacation-club style, better suited to travelers who want an easy island base with a relaxed, informal feel.
If you want the more residential, villa-forward experience, The Westin stands out; if you want casual St. Thomas ease, Margaritaville is the simpler choice.
Dining at The Westin St. John Resort Villas covers the essentials for a relaxed beach stay, with casual options, a marketplace, and a more elevated steak-and-seafood venue.
Expect:
Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas is the better fit if you want a relaxed, casual dining mood and plan to treat the resort as part of a broader St. Thomas stay.
If on-site dining variety tied to a villa resort matters more, The Westin has the edge; if casual flexibility matters more, Margaritaville keeps things easy.
The Westin St. John Resort Villas is strongest for travelers who want a true St. John beach-resort setting, with its private Great Cruz Bay beach and large freshwater pool as the main anchors.
Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas offers a more casual St. Thomas resort base, better for travelers who want an easy island atmosphere rather than the quieter St. John villa-resort feel.
If the beach and St. John setting are central to the trip, The Westin is the stronger choice; if St. Thomas convenience matters more, Margaritaville makes sense.
The Westin St. John Resort Villas is clearly family-friendly, with dedicated children’s programming and villa layouts that make it practical for families staying several nights or more.
Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas works for travelers who want an all-ages, casual vacation-club stay without the same emphasis on a villa-style family resort campus.
If kids’ programming and villa convenience are priorities, The Westin is the stronger family pick; if your group wants a casual St. Thomas stay, Margaritaville is the simpler fit.
The Westin St. John Resort Villas offers the most value when you will use the villa space, kitchens, family amenities, beach, pool, and St. John setting throughout the stay.
Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas is the better value if your priorities are a casual St. Thomas base, relaxed island energy, and simpler arrival logistics.
Choose The Westin if you want a family-friendly villa resort on St. John, with spacious accommodations, a private Great Cruz Bay beach, and a strong pool-and-kids setup.
Margaritaville is the better pick for travelers who want a casual St. Thomas vacation-club atmosphere and do not want the added ferry transfer involved in staying on St. John.
For families, longer stays, and travelers who value kitchens, villa space, and a quieter St. John setting, The Westin is the more complete choice.
If you want an easygoing St. Thomas base with a playful island style, Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas is the more relaxed fit.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for The Westin St. John Resort Villas:
